website sesame.jpg


OPEN 7-2

Monday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday, Sunday




Located at The Marketplace Shopping Center in Southern Shores, we are a delicious, convenient stop for breakfast or lunch!

We only settle for the best here at Barrier Island Bagels! Our bagels are never frozen and are made with the best ingredients on the market. We take the time to hand make our dough daily to ensure you get the freshest and most delicious bagels on the Outer Banks!


Happy to Be Healthy. Acai Bowls and Homemade Smoothies.

Got a craving for something else? We are not just a bagel shop. :) We offer many tasty breakfast and lunch options that are just as delish. At Barrier Island Bagels, our homemade and creative recipes have made BIB the perfect alternative to a boring breakfast or lunch. Breakfast here is more than just bagels with BIB’s signature smoothie and acai bowls including 7 house special smoothies plus the option to customize to your taste-buds. We love to add chia seeds, Spinach, Kale, and avocado to our smoothies too! Trying a smoothie might be the perfect addition to your breakfast bagel or signature sandwich.

Time For a Lunch Break!

For lunch our delectable deli features subs and sandwiches that will make your heart melt made with quality Boars Head meat! Our favorite lunch specialties include The Albemarle, The 158 and The OBX. Add don't forget to try our homemade chicken salad.

We love our home and want our business to thrive not just for the benefit of our family, but also our community.
— Allie + Josh Legg

About the Owners

Allison and Josh Legg are a husband and wife team with an extensive background in bagels. Having worked with Lighthouse Bagels for many years, they learned from the best of the best! Allie and Josh met and fell in love in Corolla, and were married at the beautiful Sanctuary Vineyards in Currituck. Now raising a family and running a business in Dare County, they take being a part of the Outer Banks community seriously.


(252) 255-2888


5549 N. Croatan Hwy., Southern Shores, NC 27949




We are proud to bring you the very best in homemade options for your special event. Whether it be baked goods, breakfast sandwiches, bagels with cream cheese, bagels by the dozen, lunch sandwiches, salads, or coffee, we are happy to provide you with catered meals to suit your tastes and needs.

Contact us using the form and tell us what you're looking for!

No time to wait today?

Give Allie a call at 252-255-2888!

She's happy to take your request and create a custom catered order just for you!

Name *
Phone *
Event Date
Event Date
Tell us what you're interested in.

wholesale options

Thank you for considering Barrier Island Bagels as your bagel supplier! We only settle for the best here at Barrier Island Bagel’s. Our bagels are never frozen and are made with the best ingredients on the market. We take the time to hand make  our dough daily to ensure you get the freshest and most delicious bagels in town!

We look forward to hearing from you! For pricing and/or service please contact Allie at 252-617-5169 or fill in the form and we will contact you.

Name *
Phone *


Barrier Island Bagels makes saying “thank you” easier than ever!

The Homeowner’s Program is designed to be an easy and inexpensive way home owners to say thank you to their renters. We provide three options: each including a baker’s dozen with your choice of adding a cream cheese.

  • $19/Week - Bagels Only
  • $25/Week - Bagels, 1 Cream Cheese Flavor
  • $30/Week - Bagels, 2 Cream Cheese Flavors

All you have to do is pick a plan, provide us with your information in the form adjacent, and viola! You and your renters are all set! Not only do we provide your renters with fresh, delicious bagels each week, we also monitor your plan all year to make sure you and your renters are getting what you paid for. We are looking forward to hearing from you and creating the perfect cottage program to fit your needs!


Join the Barrier Island Bagels Homeowner's Program now by filling in the form below, we will contact you afterward to finalize the details.

Name *
Address *
Please enter your home mailing address, not the address of your rental home.
Phone *
Please add the name of the company your rental home is listed with.
Please add the name of your rental home and the number associated with it by your rental company.
Please select which plan best fits your needs.

let's keep in touch